While not a member, I think this may be a useful resource for non-lawyers in Marion County. The Indianapolis Bar Association provides the follwoign information about its lawyer referral service:
Call 8:30 a.m.-4:30 p.m. Monday through Friday for a referral by phone at (317) 269-2222.
Finding a lawyer after business hours or without making a phone call can be fast, easy and FREE by filling out the form below! Simply provide us with some brief information about you and your legal needs and we will match you with a qualified attorney. If you are requesting a referral for another person, please make sure to put the correct contact information for that individual."